Workers May 'Choke' Under Pressure of Non-Monetary Incentives

Raja Kali, University of Arkansas
Photo by University Relations

Raja Kali, University of Arkansas

FAYETTEVILLE, Ark. – Competition for non-monetary awards can have adverse effects on performance and may cause employees to “choke” under pressure, according to a new study by a University of Arkansas economist.

Raja Kali, professor of economics in the Sam M. Walton College of Business, and colleagues at HEC Montreal, a business school in Canada, examined the performance of elite U.S. golfers between 2006 and 2012 and found that players underperformed when trying to qualify for the U.S. Ryder Cup team, which does not compensate them for participating.

The findings, published in the Journal of Economics & Management Strategy, challenge historical findings indicating that non-monetary incentives like plaques, rings and “employee-of-the-year” competitions motivate employees to perform better.

“In terms of broader impact or relevance to the way firms do business, these findings are important, because managers and firms in general probably do not realize that some non-monetary efforts to build morale or boost performance may not be helping,” Kali said. “In fact, they may be counterproductive.”

The researchers focused on performances of elite golfers in PGA of America tournaments that qualified them for the Ryder Cup, the prestigious competition between U.S. and European golfers. Being part of an elite group of golfers and the opportunity to represent one’s country were identified as primary incentives for participating in the Ryder Cup.

The Ryder Cup qualifying point system allocates a number of points to each PGA Tour tournament. During the qualifying period, which is typically two years, two editions of the same PGA Tour have a different value of Ryder Cup points. One year – the year previous to the Ryder Cup – there are few points, and the next year – the year of the Ryder Cup – there are many points, while all other aspects of the tournament are the same.

The researchers’ strategy was to compare the performance of players across the same tournament in two subsequent years. By focusing on blocks of the PGA Tour tournament with similar economic incentives (prize money) but different glory incentives (Ryder Cup points), they could measure the effect of the latter.

“We found significant evidence that the desire to attain glory – which, in this case, we defined as the effects of status, social esteem and respect – was a burden for player performance,” Kali said. “Furthermore, the players who underperformed the most were those who were in more desperate need of Ryder Cup points.”

The researchers wanted to understand and add to the literature on non-monetary incentives, which are widely used by firms and are generally assumed to have a positive impact on worker performance. The new study is the first to examine non-monetary incentives in a competitive, entrepreneurial setting.

It is also the first study to find evidence of diminished performance or failure – popularly referred to as “choking,” especially in the context of sports – when explicitly competing for non-monetary incentives.

“Choking under pressure, rather than risk-taking or intimidation by superstars, seems to be the reason behind underperformance, especially when the competitive pressure intensifies,” Kali said.

Kali holds the ConocoPhillips Chair in International Economics and Business.

About the University of Arkansas: The University of Arkansas provides an internationally competitive education for undergraduate and graduate students in more than 200 academic programs. The university contributes new knowledge, economic development, basic and applied research, and creative activity while also providing service to academic and professional disciplines. The Carnegie Foundation classifies the University of Arkansas among only 2 percent of universities in America that have the highest level of research activity. U.S. News & World Report ranks the University of Arkansas among its top American public research universities. Founded in 1871, the University of Arkansas comprises 10 colleges and schools and maintains a low student-to-faculty ratio that promotes personal attention and close mentoring.

Contacts

Raja Kali, professor of economics
Sam M. Walton College of Business
479-575-6219, rkali@walton.uark.edu

Matt McGowan, science and research communications officer
University Relations
479-575-4246, dmcgowa@uark.edu

Headlines

South Central Writing Centers Association Hold Conference at U of A

Writing Studio tutor Abby Long was honored as the 2024 SCWCA Tutor of the Year at the SCWCA conference earlier this month.

Transit and Parking During Spring Break Week

Razorback Transit will be running its reduced, non-peak routes and hours of service from March 18-21. There will be no service on Friday or Saturday, March 22-23.

Doctoral Candidate Successful at Arkansas Bioinformatics Consortium 2024

Hieu Bui, a doctoral student in industrial engineering, competed in the Arkansas Bioinformatics Consortium 2024 Conference held Feb. 26-27 in Little Rock.

Twelve Student Startups Competing for $100,000 at Heartland Challenge

Designed to simulate the process of raising venture capital for a high-growth enterprise, the Heartland Challenge is a global, graduate student startup competition with a prize pool of more than $100,000.

Missed Grad Salute? Graduation Regalia Still Available at U of A Bookstore

The U of A Bookstore will have graduation regalia in house to purchase until May 10. Deadline to order regalia online is April 26.

News Daily